Collecting Keys - Real Estate Investing Podcast

No-Ratio DSCR Loans Are Back: What Lenders Are Offering Now

By Mike DeHaan, Dan Austin, Dylan Koch ·

Mike DeHaan just got back from the biggest private lending conference in Las Vegas, and what he saw on the show floor should get every investor's attention. Lenders are rolling out 30-year fixed debt on property types that used to require agency financing, and at the same time they're rolling out DSCR products that the hosts say sound a lot like the "ninja" loans that preceded the 2008 crisis. This article covers what's actually being offered, where the risk-tolerant money may be coming from, and the IRS details Mike flagged on Dylan Koch's 2% seller-finance offer on a 15-unit building.

What new loan products are private lenders offering?

Mike said the biggest shift he saw was the breadth of property types now eligible for both short-term and 30-year fixed debt. He took a photo of one handout offering up to 80% on purchase and 75% on refinance for large multifamily, mixed use, retail, office, light industrial, automotive, mobile home parks, warehouse, self storage, restaurants and bars, and daycare centers. Six months ago, he said, most of that required agency debt.

Dylan joked the shorter list would be what they don't lend on. Mike said he asked specifically and found nobody doing co-living. His read: those deals try to inflate the value of a commoditized asset when every comparable property around it says otherwise. Dan added that co-living is illegal in most cities anyway.

The leverage matters as much as the term. Mike noted that when this kind of debt existed before, it often capped around 60%, meaning 40% equity. Dylan pointed out agency still tops out around 65%. Mike's view is that 30-year fixed takes the balloon and rate-adjustment risk off the table, the exact risk that has been wrecking 2021-vintage syndicators as their adjustments come due.

Dylan's counterpoint: the fact that end buyers of this debt are willing to lock 30 years suggests they don't expect rates to drop meaningfully anytime soon. Mike admitted he doesn't know where those fixed rates land and guessed they could be in the nines, which would make qualifying hard. He described the ultimate holders as life insurance companies and hedge funds that need a fixed-rate yield slice and are happy to balance-sheet an eight-and-a-half or nine percent loan for thirty years.

Are 'ninja' loans back in the private lending space?

Mike said he's seeing what he calls "sucker loans" return, the private lending version of the no-income, no-job products from 2008. He met a lender offering "no ratio" loans: a DSCR loan with no ratio requirement, down to a 0.1 DSCR, but only on cash-out, because then the lender knows the borrower has the proceeds to make payments. Dylan's reaction was blunt: "That's so stupid."

Other products Mike described from the same conference:

Where is all this risk-tolerant capital coming from?

Dylan's takeaway for listeners was simple: "Big money can be stupid." Dan's add: big money pays employees on commission, and you get the behavior you incentivize.

Mike said the source of that capital was a real topic of conversation at the conference, and he was careful to call it hypothetical. The theory several experienced people raised: when a currency is in flux, holders of wealth in those countries historically buy assets abroad. Now, instead of only buying under US shell LLCs, some are standing up lending companies and writing aggressively competitive loans. If the borrower pays, they get yield. If the borrower doesn't, they end up owning a US property instead of holding a currency they're trying to escape. Dylan compared it to a newer investor bidding against a thirty-year veteran who can leave almost nothing in a deal, just at the level of countries instead of people.

On the operations side, Mike said AI underwriting is compressing timelines. He described thirty-day closes becoming common and one lender on a 19-unit deal that can close in about a week using a model trained on its own historical underwriting data, not a generic chatbot. He also said he was surprised how far behind the lending industry is on AI adoption overall, and Dan argued most owners default to hiring an expert when they could learn enough themselves to direct the work.

What IRS rules can blow up a 2% seller-finance deal?

Dylan is making offers on small apartment buildings owned at least ten years. One is 15 units at $1.5 million, about $100,000 a unit, with the seller carrying at under 2%. Importantly, Dylan negotiated the payment, not the rate. His alternative plan: buy it and resell on a land contract with similar terms but $50,000 more down and a higher rate, netting roughly $3,000 a month in spread with none of the work. Dan's caveat was that the strategy only holds if the buyer is solid; Dylan said the buyer he has in mind is well capitalized.

Mike's warning was about the applicable federal rate. He said that at a $100,000 loan size nobody notices, but at seven figures a sub-2% note can draw attention when the long-term AFR he quoted was 5.52%. Dylan pointed out the exposure would sit with the seller on the front end. Mike also cited the Schedule B threshold of $1,500 in combined taxable interest and ordinary income, and said interest forms get issued at $10 or more.

Mike's bigger point: audits come three or four years later, penalties get backdated, interest compounds daily until paid, and he mentioned a $10,000 penalty per unreported item. He also raised depreciation recapture, which Dylan said the seller asked about directly and wanted the down payment sized to cover, at a rate Dylan put around 25%. Mike recalled a North Idaho owner who had taken accelerated depreciation on a duplex and whose recapture bill would have exceeded his remaining equity. Dylan said his own largest building, which he exchanged into and later refinanced at 80% leverage after adding value, is in a similar spot. These are general tax concepts discussed on the show, not advice, and the hosts repeatedly said to do your homework with a professional.

The full episode has more on the white-label trend among large lenders, why Mike and Dan's book is roughly half DSCR and half hard money, why ground-up construction applications are mostly weak deals, and Dylan's 23.1% property tax increase in Hamilton County. Listen to EP 518 for the whole conversation.

Frequently asked questions

What is a no-ratio DSCR loan?

Mike described it as a DSCR loan with no debt service coverage requirement, going as low as a 0.1 ratio, offered only on cash-out refinances so the lender knows the borrower holds proceeds to make payments.

Why does negotiating the payment beat negotiating the rate on seller finance?

Dylan got terms on a 15-unit at an effective rate under 2% by negotiating the monthly payment instead of the interest rate, an approach Mike said he talks about often.

Why is depreciation recapture a problem in seller-financed sales?

Dylan's seller had about twenty years of depreciation and wanted the down payment large enough to cover recapture; Mike recalled a case where the recapture bill exceeded the owner's remaining equity.

Private Money & LendingCreative Finance, Subject-To & Novations

Educational content from the Collecting Keys podcast. Not financial, legal or tax advice.